Here's my more detailed review of Side By Side based on 6 categories. The 1st 3 of these categories,test of pricing skill,fun,and fairness deal with the gameplay aspects. The 2nd 3 of these categories,set,sound effects,and reveal deal with intangibles. The other category will address anything miscellaneous.
Test of Pricing Skill: 5 out of 10: Obviously a 50/50 game isn't the greatest test of pricing skill. However it's better if the range between the options is optimum. If the difference is less than $1000 then it becomes a random guessing game. If the difference is over $3000 the choice may become obvious. The ideal difference between the 2 options is $1500 to $2500. While I gave Double Prices and Coming or Going 4 out of 10 for test of pricing skill I'm going 1 point higher on Side by Side because it's more common for Side By Side to have this ideal setup.
Fun factor: 6 out of 10: The pricing portion of this game is pretty dull. But watching the contestant slide the tile into place is far more enjoyable than watching the contestant set the price in Coming or Going. The great reveal means the ending is always fun.
Fairness: 10 out of 10: Making the right price selection ensures a win. Side by Side is a fair game.
Set: 9 out of 10: This set is fantastic. It's nifty in a simple kind of way. The sliding tiles are infinitely superior to the sliding numbers in Coming or Going. And the reveal display has pizzazz.
Sound effects: N/A: Side By Side doesn't have sound effects.
Reveal: 10 out of 10: THIS is what makes this game so superior to Coming or Going. The lightup style is such a fun and awesome way of doing a reveal. The lighted reveal display has pizzazz and the sorry indicator is unique to Side by Side. Great stuff.

Other: Considering how great the reveal is I'm changing my overall grade for Side by Side to 7 out of 10.