Author Topic: New Pricing Game Review: TELEPHONE GAME  (Read 13233 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline kingpin623

  • In Contestant's Row
  • ***
  • Posts: 228
Re: New Pricing Game Review: TELEPHONE GAME
« Reply #15 on: April 15, 2014, 05:56:02 PM »
I would've been 4 or 5 years old during this game's all-too-fleeting run, but honestly don't recall seeing it.

From what it sounds, the game does seem interesting.  I honestly don't think the game was lame.  Why would someone retire a pricing game because of it being lame?

I too had to question that reasoning at first.  Lame?  Nah, couldn't be that lame!  But after watching the last airing -- and the only win -- of this game on YouTube (thanks, Wink!), I can see why they retired it for being lame.  The win was somehow anticlimactic with the contestant standing there, holding a phone, listening to it ring and waiting for it to be answered...  And even when it was revealed that he won a car, he could do little more than wave his arms around a bit because he had a phone up to his ear!  (It was either that or drop the phone and leave it dangling on its cord, or else get so excited that he jumped around and yanked it out of the socket!).

This was long-rumored to be a game played for three 4-digits prizes that could all be won just by matching one prize's 3-digit "exchange" with its 4-digit price "extension"; ironically, that sounds like a much more interesting concept than the game as it was in reality!

This game might actually be more feasible for Let's Make a Deal, as part of its premise is the chance of winning a car versus a 2-digit priced prize.

This game may have worked a bit better if there was a giant push-button phone on stage that the contestant dialed by doing a CPR/chest compression-like push with both hands onto each button, with the corresponding prize lighting up and ringing immediately.

As for the grocery portion of this game:  yeah, giving the contestant the phone call for "free" wouldn't do much to alleviate this game's lameness, but the way they go about earning the phone call is a bit convoluted.  Worse still is the thought of how lame a playing would be if they didn't earn the phone call (sort of which we see in Master Key, Secret X, and 5 Price Tags on occasion now).

I'll give it a 5/10:  unique concept, but just not all that exciting.

JBK

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: TELEPHONE GAME
« Reply #16 on: May 10, 2014, 04:54:56 PM »
The outdatedness of this game makes it a good thing it was retired. I like the GP portion of the game and I'd like to see some variation of the GP portion of this game made into a standalone GP game. You could have a standalone GP game where 6 GPs were shown along with a spending limit and to win the contestant would have to pick the 3 GPs whose total ARP did not exceed the spending limit ala the 90 cent limit here. If the contestant stayed within the spending limit he/she would win the prize. However the 2nd part of this game is goofy,outdated,and unintentionally"meh" Perhaps I'd think differently if I'd seen this game live but the sight of a massive oversized landline type phone just looks goofy as hell to me. The outdated aspect speaks for itself as nowadays over a quarter of American households don't even have landline phones as we live in the cell phone era. I was struggling to articulate how to describe the"meh" of this game after seeing it but I think a previous poster was onto something when he talked how contestants in this game were restrained from showing natural reactions to winning because of holding a huge phone in their hands during the reveal. Then of course there's nothing overly exciting about the style of reveal in and of itself. Just dial a number and wait for a response. Yawn. Another flaw I noticed in the YouTube video was that 2 of the 3 possible prices for the car were less than $100 apart. Even in 1978 that's not enough of a difference and introduces a randomness factor. By 1978 standards the price choices should have at least been $200 apart from each other. By today's standards I'd say the potential prices should all be at least $1200 apart from each other.  Overall I really like the GP portion of the game but overall it's not very good and it's outdatedness sticks out like a sore thumb. 3 out of 10. Let's keep this game in the pricing game graveyard where it belongs.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: TELEPHONE GAME
« Reply #17 on: July 05, 2014, 04:18:35 PM »
My final word on Telephone Game: This might not be the worst game in TPIR history but it is the 1 that most belongs in the retired category. Regardless of anything else about Telephone Game the extreme outdated feeling it would have if it were active today by itself means we are so much better off without it.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline pannoni1

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 1280
Re: New Pricing Game Review: TELEPHONE GAME
« Reply #18 on: May 04, 2015, 07:56:31 AM »
I'm glad that this game only got played three times, the second shortest lifespan of any pricing game. Although this game was won once, having a qualifying round in which you're only playing just to get to the real portion of the game is not only time-consuming, but leads to disappointment in case the game ends at this point which can frustrate viewers. At least in other progressive games such as More or Less, the prizes behorehand can be useful compared to just grocery products. Obviously if this game kept on going for some strange reason, they would have to up the starting range to $2 and perhaps $5 today, as its nearly impossible to find two grocery items for under 90 cents these days. Eventually the "phone book" would have five digits with the value of the cars and SPs as time progressed and that wouldn't have been as awkward. Who knows how manipulative the four GPs were, as one setup could have been 40 cents, 50 cents, 55 cents, and 60 cents leaving just one possible combination while another could have been 35 cents, 40 cents, 50 cents, and 60 cents leaving three "good" picks. While this was a fair game, picking the price of the car from the three choices was fairly difficult (equivalent to $17,580, $17,956, and $18,792 as choices today say if you multiplied the prices of the only car that was one by four to account for inflation) making it close to a guessing game. The font of course is VERY '70s that suggests the earliest PCs. It definitely was one of the most boring pricing games on the show since at least Double Prices usually has reasonable guess and by being quick allows more time for other games. Unfortunately, Telephone Game was a longer car/fee game. The only credit I'll give is the use of three models answering their own "phone" which was a slightly more interesting reveal.

Grade: D
Now open for tape trading! Please PM me for an offer with a list included.

The list: https://yelimsexa.wixsite.com/pannoni1