Heaven help me, I’m about to criticize one of the most revered games on the show.
Yes, I know this is one of the “big three”. Yes, I know it’s a classic that goes back decades. Yes, I know that speaking evil of one of the show’s premier games on the site that bears its name probably isn’t what people want to hear, but here goes…
*deep breath*
The gameplay isn’t that great.
"What? He dares criticize Golden Road, one of the greatest pricing games ever created?"
See, it’s not much of a *pricing* game. It’s a “guess your favorite number” game. It’s “fake” pricing, the sort where an LFAT who watches the show every day has about as much chance as winning as any random nervous person who throws their hands up and just lets the audience guide them.
Yeah, the first prize is trivially easy. It has to be. The game would suck if many people got caught on it without any buildup. The second one is always harder—usually *too* much harder. Can anyone *really* be expected to know whether that hot tub is $7,800 or $7,900?
Oh, and if you’re wrong, the game ends. All that set up? Wasted. You don’t even get to *see* the part you really wanted to see. No chance at building up suspense to the big prize.
But if they do make it that far, how do you win the final prize? By taking a random 1-in-4 guess. Even a contestant who’s gone shopping for a Dodge Viper a week ago won’t be able to guess the hundreds digit of a particular configuration with any degree of confidence. It’s a “pick your favorite number” game disguised as pricing.
"What? TONS of games require luck to win! And TONS of games, especially car games, require you to guess hard-to-price digits!"
Yeah, there’s nothing *wrong* with that—a lot of great games are really “pick your favorite number” games. But I’m a little bothered that the biggest game on the show isn’t really about pricing--but "fake" pricing. At least Plinko is upfront about being a luck-based game. At least 3 Strikes gives you multiple chances at the trickier numbers. In fact, most games that ask for obscure numbers in the car's price give you multiple chances at it to keep things fair. Golden Road doesn't. Unless the setup is especially generous and has a repeat digit, there really aren't any tricks to help you.
As the final sacrilegious note in this profane tirade, even Pay The Rent is a better test of pricing for big money than Golden Road is. High-stakes grocery item pricing is a far more interesting idea than "pricing" a car most people have never seen before.
"Boo! Heresy! Pay the Rent, a better pricing game than Golden Road? Take his LFaT card, throw him out on the street, and burn him at the stake!"
Hang on, I said it was a better test of pricing, not a better pricing game. Pay the Rent has many other problems that keep it from greatness. But now that I’ve deflated Golden Road’s balloon a little bit, let’s take a look at how great this game *really* is.
What this game excels at is presentation, presentation, presentation. It’s freaking huge! The whole set is used! A big, honking, glitzy sign! Giant turntables covered in colored mirror shards! Or, when they’re not used—prizes behind every door on the set! The floor becomes golden!
And to top it all off, the big reveal… a luxury car on a giant spinning turntable with a rainbow while frigging pyrotechnics go off! No expense is spared, this game feels like one of the biggest games on the show and it sells it. Good gravy, does it ever sell it. Best set on the show, bar none, nothing else comes close.
And the hosting opportunities? These are the real gold. This is where the host can pull out all the stops and really make the game feel like you're witnessing a Big Historic Event. Plinko doesn’t have that. Pay The Rent certainly doesn’t. Even Three Strikes, great as it is, doesn’t have opportunities for that intense host buildup.
This was one of Bob’s best. He pulled out all the stops for this game. Watching him tease the contestant pulling the tab and build suspense was nothing short of masterful. Bob made the game one of the all-time greats. I didn’t care if it was fake pricing--it was the best show in town. Nothing compared to it. It was unforgettable. They were “viral moments” that got burned in your memories forever.
Now, Drew does a good job, but IMO the game needs somebody like Bob, a professional milker, for the game to really hit its full potential. Drew isn’t a tease—it’s not in his nature. He’s not gonna torture the contestant any more than he has to. This is more humane, but it has tempered my reaction to be closer to “nice to see Golden Road show up again!” than “HOLY CRAP HOLY CRAP IT’S GOLDEN ROAD”.
But it’s still frigging great.
★★★★☆