Here's my more detailed review of Magic Number based on 6 categories. The 1st 3 of these categories, test of pricing skill, fun, and fairness will deal with the gameplay aspects. The 2nd 3 categories, set, sound effects, and reveal deal with intangibles. The other category will address anything miscellaneous.
Test of pricing skill: 10 out of 10: Not only do you have good feel for value judgment in determining which GPs go with which range but to win the full prize you have to place all 5 correctly on the 1st try. Misjudge even 1 and you're not winning the top prize. And to win anything you have to place all 5 correctly within 20 seconds. Having to get all 5 right makes this a great test of pricing skill.
Fun factor: 10 out of 10: The play along at factor is good. The 2nd part of the game, when it's needed, is a huge improvement from the 2nd chance concept of yesteryear. What timed games need to work is a guess, test and revise element that allows as many guesses as you can muster in the allotted. This adds a rapid fire element that doesn't exist if it's just make 1 choice in 20 seconds. The decreasing prize factor also adds a dramatic element to Time is Money that makes it more fun still. The improved set and fun sound effects and reveal also help the fun factor.
Fairness: 10 out of 10: If a contestant gets it right the 1st time he or she wins the full prize. After that, the better he or she does the more he or she wins. What could be fairer than that?
Set: What an improvement: While brown is both dull/lifeless AND a poor fit for the presentation of The Price is Right, the silver and green look incredibly sharp and it's a cool big set too. Not entirely how to describe the look of the now set.
Sound effects: 10 out of 10: I know a lot of you would prefer some kind of think music in those 1st 10 seconds but I personally loved the store check out like beeping. It's a sound effect that's not used in any other game so it gives Time is Money more uniqueness. I like that. I just enjoyed it anyway.
Reveal: 10 out of 10: Uniqueness rules again. The circular door like things rotating to open up was a pretty unique and cool rveal. Great idea.
Other: The key word to describe the new Time is Money is uniqueness. the gameplay, evaporating prize, set, sound effects, and reveal are all unique. That is a major reason the overall score is 10 out of 10.
My final word on the new Time is Money: I hope Time is Money becomes a regular biweekly game and I wouldn't mind seeing it in back to back weeks a few times a season. A lesson to be learned here is that sometimes it's worth giving something a 2nd chance. The original Time is Money was a case of good concept bad execution. It's really cool to have an old game come back and be so much better in it's 2nd life. A round of applause for Price for throwing an 80 yard touchdown pass on the new Time is Money.