I'm sorry, but I didn't like this game. It was a good concept, but it had bad execution.
Add 'em Up is a game that was played for a car. You'll notice nearby that there's a certain total (for example, 18 total) - That means the car price adds to 18 total. However, there was a major gripe that made me dislike the game - it's due to how unforgiving the game is with mistakes. The contestant is only allowed one mistake the entire game, so if he adds incorrectly twice in the game, the game is over. Thankfully, the contestant is allowed which digit of the car price he or she wants. (Never go with the first digit).
Of course, my dislike in this game is due to how difficult this game is. What didn't help bring this game to an early retirement was that it had some bad contestants (see the Season 16 finale). Though it's not like Pass the Buck (which is worse), it still isn't a game I would play. If you had two mistakes instead of one, and the game was easier to understand, then this game may still be with us today. However, due to how unforgiving this game was with errors (though, nowhere near the ridiculousness that was found in Trader Bob) and how confusing it was to some contestants, the game was retired early.
The plus-shaped board was a positive tangent, and it was okay. I think I'll give Add 'em Up a 4/10. I could never get into it, and there was very little room for error. It's not one of my favourites, I'll give you that.