The presentation and cash offer is why Punch-A-Bunch can be a good game to watch. However, it falls short on pricing concept originality and of course, fairness. First off, no new ground was broken in pricing skill/concept, not just being a Bonus Game/Shell Game clone, but with the setups usually being easier. At least with the later, it usually allows for more of what we want to see: the big Punchboard with 50 holes with dollar signs and blue neon surrounding it. I like both sets in different ways, with the original being more classic (I'd wish they didn't change the Punch-A-Bunch sign from multicolored to yellow) to a funky yet cool-looking pastel set used since 1996. It still preserves the harps used in the intro along with the oversized bill with the host on it that really captivated me as a kid whenever this game would show up.
I do like however that if you don't win any prizes, you don't get any punches resulting in a true loss. I do miss the Second Chance cards (yet another victim of added time for commercials/promos) since these often led to more bailouts, along with the rare win over $10,000. That said, with an average win of around $1,000 during the earlier setup and $2,185 with four punches today as explained by JRR4, the amount of cash won does seem to be a bit small compared to even Plinko. That said, the suspense/reveals are always one of the strongest points of the game, with higher amounts often leading to a buildup by the host. I miss Bob's when he mention questions such as "How much money before you want to quit?", along with himself rambling over "throwing away" money going on even if its a relatively small amount like $250.
The short-lived concept early in Punch-a-Bunch's life that actually used the letters in the word PUNCHBOARD actually was quite interesting in that you could only win one punch at a time, although I'm glad that was removed so that you have a better idea of when to stop along with the reduction of silly payouts from $1-$10, in which 20 of the holes contained the dreaded "DOLLARS" slip.
Overall, while the pricing acept is sort of a sideshow like Plinko, it is still one of the most enjoyed games in which the fun and presentation triumphs over what technical flaws the game provides. It works great in any slot (especially first, second, fifth, or sixth) and makes a good biweekly to triweekly games. Like someone else had said, it was Deal or No Deal decades before the show existed and closer in spirit to Treasure Hunt at the time the game was created.
Grade: B