Author Topic: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)  (Read 28589 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline bonusguy810

  • In Contestant's Row
  • ***
  • Posts: 150
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #45 on: October 24, 2013, 07:28:40 PM »
Well, it may not be the same as it used to be, but unlike "Pick-a-Pair", this game is still enjoyable. The first game ever to offer cash, and it's a classic to this date. When Bob was hosted, he was at his best in this game, because he knew just how to build up suspense for a great win here. Drew can't really do it. I'm glad it got the top prize got increased, but this format isn't the way to do it. If you want $25k won, just add another $25k slip, and you can end that long losing streak. The game hasn't been won in 5 1/2 years, and that's partially why it's not as fun, as it used to be. It's not a bad game, and it's still a classic in my book, but it's just not that much fun anymore. So, I think I'll give it a 7/10.
If it's not broke, don't fix it.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #46 on: January 23, 2014, 09:21:26 PM »
I'm not big on punch a bunch. Perfect pricing can still result in only $100 so it's a blatantly unfair game. While watching the punches is undeniably fun perfect pricing counts for far too little in this game. 3 out of 10.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #47 on: February 11, 2014, 08:18:07 PM »
Here's my more detailed review of Punch a Bunch based on 6 categories. The 1st 3 of these categories,test of pricing skill,fun,and fairness will deal with gameplay aspects. The 2nd 3 of these categories,set,sound effects,and reveal will deal with intangibles. The other category will address anything miscellaneous.

Test of pricing skill: 8 out of 10: The higher/lower concept is good. Pricing an item to determine if it's ARP is higher or lower than a shown price is a good test of pricing skill:

Fun factor: 8 out of 10: The higher/lower concept has a strong play along at home factor and it's fun to watch the contestant punching the holes.

Fairness: 4 out of 10: While not quite as extremely unfair as Secret X,Plinko,and 1/2 off Punch a Bunch is still an unfair game as perfect pricing allows for the possibility of only $100.

Set: 6 out of 10: I like the way Punch a Bunch is spelled out in colorful letters at the top of the game board. Other than that this set doesn't do much for me.

Sound effects: 5 out of 10: The only sound effect is the sound of the paper as the contestant makes his/her punches. Nothing to like or dislike. Just kind of"there."

Reveal: 6 out of 10: The unfolding of the slips is a somewhat unique way of doing the reveal. However this game has proven to be Drew's weakest. He tends to give away the result by almost trying to force the suspense. When he says"darn it" you pretty know a fairly good result is coming. When he says" "well you got" in a kind of hopeful voice you know we're likely to see $500 or less. When Bob was hosting this category would've gotten a 9 out of 10.

Other: Somehow the low fairness score doesn't damage the fun factor in this game the way it does in most games where perfect pricing still allows for a loss perhaps because the pricing portion feels more detached from the rest of the game than in say,Plinko or 1/2 off.  While there's no way to make Punch a Bunch truly fair it could be improved in the following ways. 1. Eliminate the $100 and $250 slips and replace them with $750 and $1500. This would eliminate the nominally low amounts. 2. add a $500 bonus for perfect pricing. 3. Eliminate the bailout and make the highest slip revealed the amount won. This would increase the fairness score to 6 as it would remove the possibility of better pricing leading to less. While 1/2 off could be fixed by adding a 4th set of SPs Punch a Bunch isn't really fixable. But it could be made fairer than it is with the above suggestions especially eliminating the bailout and making the highest revealed slip the amount won. Punch a Bunch might also be better as a rare once every 2 months game. After my more detailed review I'll increase my overall score to 4 out of 10. Eliminating the bailout and making the highest revealed slip the amount won would make this game fairer enough to go up to 5 or 6 in overall score but it's never going to be a great game.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #48 on: August 10, 2014, 06:21:08 PM »
My final word on Punch a Bunch: Though not exactly a fair game and not entirely fixable Punch a Bunch is much more tolerable than Plinko. 1 notable difference between Plinko and Punch a Bunch is that the ability to enjoy Punch a Bunch as a viewer isn't overly results oriented. It's really fun in and of itself to watch contestants punch holes on the game board. This means great results aren't required to enjoy watching Punch a Bunch. It's aso important to remember that amongst all games that have a pricing portion and a 2nd portion Punch a Bunch is the 1 in which the 2nd portion feels most detached from the pricing portion. Truthfully there isn't a huge difference between 2, 3, or 4 punches. In 1/2 Off each correct guess is huge. Each chip in Plinko is huge, each card in Spelling Bee is huge. In Punch a Bunch number of punches isn't that critical. This detachment feeling prevents the unfair"feeling" from becoming dominant and as such the relative unfairness doesn't damage the fun factor that much. That being said what I would ultimately do with Punch a Bunch is eliminate the bailout aspect and award each contestant the highest amount he/she punched. This would make Punch a Bunch fairer than it is because each punch won would then just become 1 more chance at the big prize. No more need to risk a $1000 or $2500 amount from the 1st punch under this scenario. In this scenario better pricing just means more opportunities to win a higher amount and that would be fairer than what we have now. And I would also at least institute a $500 minimum rule for perfect pricing if we're going to keep the current distributions. Higher/lower is a strong enough test of pricing skill that perfect pricing using this concept needs to be acknowledged somehow. I'd prefer a $500 bonus for perfect pricing but at least have a house minimum for perfect pricing if you won't do that. As for slotting it doesn't really matter in Punch a Bunch. Punch a Bunch is pretty much the same experience regardless of where it appears in lineups. Although not a weekly game Punch a Bunch is a pretty regular game and sometimes occurs in back to back weeks. Again I don't think frequency matters much for Punch a Bunch. It's not a special game that needs to be kept special by being infrequent and nor is it a game with a big law of diminishing returns issue. It shows up when it shows up and that's okay. Punch a Bunch can never be made truly fair but it could be greatly improved by going to a keep the highest amount you punch format and by acknowledging perfect pricing in some way. These improvements would make Punch a Bunch a good game as the pricing concept is already strong with a fun play along at home factor and watching contestants punch the board is fun. Though not entirely capable of being a fair game Punch a Bunch is too popular for retiring to be an option so the best thing to do would be to make improvements to it to maximize possible fairness.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline JRR4

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 89
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #49 on: October 08, 2014, 04:52:14 PM »
I did some calculations regarding the current PaB configuration and I determined that no matter what pick you are on, or what amounts you have selected prior, the average amount you will select is always between $1659.57 and $2185.11.  Therefore, if you are playing the odds, stop once you hit a $2500.00 slip. 

Here's how I did the math:
On first pick the average amount selected is the sum of all slips / 50 = $103,000 / 50 = $2060.00
On the second pick the best average amount is if the first pick was $100: $102,900 / 49 = $2100.00 
On the second pick the worst average amount is if the first pick was $10,000: $93,000 / 49 = $1897.96 (who's gonna pass on $10,000 though for one $25,000 slip)
On the third pick the best average amount is if the first 2 picks were $100: $102,800 / 48 = $2141.67 
On the third pick the worst average amount is if the first 2 picks were $10,000: $83,000 / 48 = $1729.17 (who's gonna pass on $10,000 twice though for one $25,000 slip)
On the fourth pick the best average amount is if the first 3 picks were $100: $102,700 / 47 = $2185.11 
On the fourth pick the worst average amount is if the first 3 picks were $10,000, $10,000 and $5000.00: $78,000 / 47 = $1659.57 (who's gonna pass on $10,000 twice though for one $25,000 slip)

Am I correct?


 

Offline pannoni1

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 1280
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #50 on: July 14, 2015, 11:07:40 AM »
The presentation and cash offer is why Punch-A-Bunch can be a good game to watch. However, it falls short on pricing concept originality and of course, fairness. First off, no new ground was broken in pricing skill/concept, not just being a Bonus Game/Shell Game clone, but with the setups usually being easier. At least with the later, it usually allows for more of what we want to see: the big Punchboard with 50 holes with dollar signs and blue neon surrounding it. I like both sets in different ways, with the original being more classic (I'd wish they didn't change the Punch-A-Bunch sign from multicolored to yellow) to a funky yet cool-looking pastel set used since 1996. It still preserves the harps used in the intro along with the oversized bill with the host on it that really captivated me as a kid whenever this game would show up.

I do like however that if you don't win any prizes, you don't get any punches resulting in a true loss. I do miss the Second Chance cards (yet another victim of added time for commercials/promos) since these often led to more bailouts, along with the rare win over $10,000. That said, with an average win of around $1,000 during the earlier setup and $2,185 with four punches today as explained by JRR4, the amount of cash won does seem to be a bit small compared to even Plinko. That said, the suspense/reveals are always one of the strongest points of the game, with higher amounts often leading to a buildup by the host. I miss Bob's when he mention questions such as "How much money before you want to quit?", along with himself rambling over "throwing away" money going on even if its a relatively small amount like $250.

The short-lived concept early in Punch-a-Bunch's life that actually used the letters in the word PUNCHBOARD actually was quite interesting in that you could only win one punch at a time, although I'm glad that was removed so that you have a better idea of when to stop along with the reduction of silly payouts from $1-$10, in which 20 of the holes contained the dreaded "DOLLARS" slip.

Overall, while the pricing acept is sort of a sideshow like Plinko, it is still one of the most enjoyed games in which the fun and presentation triumphs over what technical flaws the game provides. It works great in any slot (especially first, second, fifth, or sixth) and makes a good biweekly to triweekly games. Like someone else had said, it was Deal or No Deal decades before the show existed and closer in spirit to Treasure Hunt at the time the game was created.

Grade: B
Now open for tape trading! Please PM me for an offer with a list included.

The list: https://yelimsexa.wixsite.com/pannoni1

Offline Tech_Triumph

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 44
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PUNCH-A-BUNCH (PUNCHBOARD)
« Reply #51 on: June 24, 2019, 03:30:05 PM »
When you compare Punch-A-Bunch to the other pricing games today, the overall payout for winning is simply lacking. I know cash is better, but considering how hard it is to win $5,000 when contestants are winning that much on easier games such as Magic Number, Push Over, etc, it's simply not paying off like it should.

The set is classic and it's a great game for contestants who are not avid fans, but they may need to tweak this a little bit. I'm thinking either reduce the number of squares or keep the current format and aggregate the winnings until the final slot. Whatever it is, this game needs some small adjustments given the lack of even medium sized winners.

Heck, you can play the game perfectly and easily walk away with the same money or less than a perfect bid on contestants' row.

Overall: 4 of 10. Should be so much better.