Waaaay back when Drew took over as host there were rumors that one game would be getting the axe. Something about Drew only learning 75 games, but there were 76 games in the rotation at the time. People started counting down and they quickly figured out that neither Poker Game nor Joker had been played with Drew as a host. And so everybody here started debating over which one would they rather save.
Now, I was young and time has taken its toll on my memories, but if I remember correctly, the consensus opinion was that Poker Game was a long-running classic that deserved to be carried forward to the Drew Era, while the obviously inferior Joker deserved to die as a waste of pricing game space.
You know what? Those people are all crazy. Poker Game blows.
First, the thing was ancient. Not "classic", but tacky and rinkydink. It premiered in 1975, and didn’t make much effort to hide it. The podiums where chintzy and cheap--much like the prizes they represented—and the board wasn’t a huge improvement. The fonts and graphics attempt to evoke Old Vegas, but instead they just evoke Old. Those sportstype displays kinda, sorta look like cards in a playing hand, but you really gotta use your imagination here, cause cards don’t look like that. And that ugly giant clown head on top kind of seals the deal.
But the set’s the least of this thing’s problems. The rules are a mess. “Pick a bunch of repeating numbers?” What in the world is that supposed to mean? Who thought this could pass as “pricing”? The only real strategy is “play” or “pass”!
If you have a good first hand, you hold it and cross your fingers that neither of the other prizes are $555 or $899 or whatever. If you have a bad first hand, you pass it and hope that you can find something better. That’s it. No “pricing” involved. In fact, the prices only muddle the concept further. When you could literally pull random numbers from a hopper and it would be an improvement, that’s bad.
It doesn’t help that not everybody is born knowing which poker hands beat which. When turning an existing game into a pricing game, simpler, universal concepts are better. Secret X works because it’s easy to explain the rules to Tic-Tac-Toe. Hit Me has a huge problem being understood if the viewer or the contestant hasn’t seen blackjack before. Poker Game’s not quite as bad in that regard, but it’s still pretty out there. As a young kid I had to see more than a few playings (and a little help from the rules in the board game) before it made sense.
I never saw a case where Bob had to explain this game to somebody who had never played poker before, but good luck getting a nervous contestant to understand “try to find lots of repeating numbers”. It’s really the sort of thing you have to see in action once or twice before it clicks, but of course you don’t have that luxury when you’re dealing with a nervous contestant.
I’m really scratching my head how this thing lasted so long. There must have been somebody backstage that REALLY liked poker. The thing that really gets me is that for as much crap as I’ve given it, it’s not at all a bad adaptation of something as complex as poker. Get rid of the prices, generate the numbers at random, and it would be a perfect fit for one of those lottery shows or Let’s Make a Deal. But on The Price is Right, it sticks out like a sore thumb. No wonder they only played it like twice a season.
In the end, history tells us that we were hoodwinked by those Poker v Joker rumors. Neither would survive the transition into the Drew Era, and both games are now living it up in the Great Pricing Game Storage Facility In The Sky. Both were flawed, and neither would have been very good fits for Drew’s hosting style. But hey--Joker was at least a pricing game.
★☆☆☆☆