Author Topic: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO  (Read 42020 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Coupon Boy

  • Walking the Golden Road
  • ****
  • Posts: 423
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #45 on: March 05, 2015, 07:28:50 AM »
I think the Plinko cash distribution is fine as it is, keeping in mind that:

1. It still has the largest average winnings of any cash game save the new incarnation of Time is Money.

2. It has BY FAR the most generous cash distribution out of all the foreign versions of the Price is Right.
Won $79,525 on my first Host Your Own game.

Offline ausmic1

  • In Contestant's Row
  • ***
  • Posts: 130
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #46 on: August 01, 2015, 09:56:10 PM »
This game is pretty overrated. The pricing aspect is unique but the chip-dropping becomes anticlimatic if four or less chips are earned or the first two chips fall in a slot other than the $10,000. Under the current format and winning definition, the game will never be fully won. It's pretty disappointing to see this game on a show that has 5 wins and is automatically spoiled by the near-impossible winning odds. If I could change this game in any way, I would change the slot amounts using an all or nothing approach such as this:

$0/$10,000/$0/$10,000/$0/$10,000/$0/$10,000/$0

It would still take a while for the $50,000 win to occur, but I'm sure it would eventually happen under such a format. Plinko is still a game that is beloved by viewers and is well worth having in the rotation. But personally, I've never cared for it due to the impossible winning standards. As it is, I give Plinko a 5/10. Not remarkable, but not bad either.

Offline Coupon Boy

  • Walking the Golden Road
  • ****
  • Posts: 423
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #47 on: August 15, 2015, 03:45:50 PM »
Does it REALLY matter whether this game is technically a loss when someone wins $10,000+? :-? If winning $41,000 makes me a loser, I'd gladly "lose" this game all day long. :biggrin:
Won $79,525 on my first Host Your Own game.

Offline tpir04

  • Taking a Bonus Spin
  • *****
  • Posts: 998
  • Why, oh why?
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #48 on: June 25, 2019, 09:42:25 AM »
It's most popular game on the show. Let's discuss.

Set: So, there's a lot to see here. Being as though the game has been around since 1983, it's undergone a few set changes. The rainbow set had a lot of old-style charm,  but the current set fits quite well into the LCD-dominated stage. (By the way, the nostalgic in me wants the old Plinko turntable sign back.)

Gameplay: The pricing portion of this game is certainly original. Decide whether the first or last number is correct. For every correct guess, you earn a chip. There's something to be said about watching chips bounce down the board. Unfortunately, most of the time, the game is very predictable. If the contestant drops a chip down the side, there's a good chance it will remain on that side. On the other hand, if a chip is right down the center, hovering over the $10k slot and the $0 slot, there's a lot of suspense, culminating in either a big letdown, if it lands in the $0, or lots of excitement, if it lands in the $10k.

My take: Two things bug me about Plinko. First, the top prize will never be won! But if it is won, it will certainly be a YouTube-worthy moment. Second, it doesn't matter how many chips you have, there's always a chance that they will all land in the $0. Even though there are two $0 slots and one $10k slot, and thus the chance of a wipeout is twice as likely, I suppose you still have to balance the good with the bad. With that, I'd like to present yet another cash distribution, although the current one works just fine.

$1000|$0|$500|$100|$10,000|$100|$500|$0|$1000

This increases the chance of winning something, albeit only $100, if you aim for the middle.

It's a great game, and the most popular as well. Many here would like to see it retired, but I wouldn't. All this being said, Plinko gets a 9.5/10.
CSS: Exacta, 6/3/2019
Lifetime earnings: $1,896,732
Season 18 cash earnings: $629,243
Season 19 cash earnings: $490,110
FPG: 2019-2020 Finals Champion
...............................

Live for the present.  Embrace the future.  Our favorite game show is still producing excellent, high quality, exciting, hour-long* shows every weekday throughout its traditional season window.  It’s as good as it’s been in a long, long time.  If the 1980s were the ‘good ole days’ for the Barker era, so is RIGHT NOW for the Carey era.  Don’t worry about what the future holds.  It will play out in due time.  Enjoy what we have right in front of us in the meantime!

Offline WOF85

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 55
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #49 on: July 13, 2019, 02:37:38 AM »
This game is the worst game the show ever made in my opinion. Yes worse than Double Digits, Bullseye I, and other failures of pricing games. And I have reasons to loathe this game. 

Plinko is the only 2 part pricing game that requires perfection in both halves. So off the bat a contestant is smacked by a 1/16 odds of getting all 4 SPs right and getting all 5 chips total. These odds are already steep enough and even though other games have 1/16 odds of perfection in the 1st half, if they are perfected; they are instant winners (I.E. Bonus Game), car games with reason to have a loss still possible (I.E. 5 Price Tags) or the contestant will still get something guaranteed (I.E. Punch A Bunch). Plinko has none of those. It's possible to get all 5 chips and get bupkus at the end. So that issue times the (1/9)^5 or 1/59049 odds of dropping all 5 chips in the 10k slpt leads the game to having the rough odds of 1/944,784.

Furthermore its set is ugly, the gimmicks fall flat over and over. It's an old hat but it somehow mesmerizes people like car keys in front of a baby.

Lastly, other pricing games have driven in more coffin nails. Pay The Rent has take away Plinko's long time saving grace of being the highest cash game. Moreover unlike Plinko, Pay The Rent has been won a few times. As if that was not bad enough for Plinko, pricing games not normally played for high cash amounts have given away more than Plinko has in one playing. Because of Big Money Week Hole In One and Let 'Em Roll have given away 100k cash prizes.

The only positive is the SP portion being unique even if it's a 50/50 set up.

Garbage from day 1 and garbage until the end. Because let's face facts. The only way Plinko will be retired is if the show comes to an end.
Plinko is the worst game the show ever made.

Offline TPIRfan#9821

  • 4/23/2020
  • TPiR Alumnus
  • *
  • Posts: 880
  • ghost in the more-than-shell bedroom
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #50 on: July 13, 2019, 03:38:33 AM »
^You know what? Allow me to counter your argument. I don't necessarily feel that Plinko is the best game, but it is certainly far from the worst.

Quote
Plinko is the only 2 part pricing game that requires perfection in both halves.

I mean, if you mean to be purely won for $50,000, sure. I don't think that Ryan Belz, who won $31,500, really thinks he is a loser. I get sticking to the standard that it isn't a "perfect show" if every other game is won and Plinko has $41,000. However, I mainly see this more of a technicality based on some standards that I don't even truly know the origin of; I wouldn't be complaining if I got $41,000.

Quote
(paraphrasing) Perfect pricing should be an instant win, have a second half based solely on pricing, or have at least something guaranteed to be won. Plinko can have perfect pricing and still end up with $0

Technically, the contestant wins the small prizes. However, in a strict sense, this logic could be applied to Rat Race (although the odds of picking 3 rats that all malfunction are slim), Pass the Buck (which could technically end up on the third pick as a LOSE EVERYTHING, when going for a car with $4,000 accumulated), or Joker (I know it's retired, but you brought up retired games in the beginning of your argument)

Even if you don't believe those, two major offenders that also have that problem are Secret X (Which has a 1/3 to be lost with perfect play if the center Xs were truly random), and 3 Strikes (which the odds of drawing 3 Strikes on the first three picks, about a 1.8% chance, are much higher than wiping out with 5 chips). To be fair, I've seen people bash Secret X sometimes for that activity, but I have seen that generally, the big prize at the end of Strikes justifies the randomness. Why wouldn't that be the same thing here, where at least you could get a partial win?

Quote
Furthermore its set is ugly, the gimmicks fall flat over and over. It's an old hat but it somehow mesmerizes people like car keys in front of a baby.

Ugly is very subjective. If anything, I'd consider Check-Out to be loads uglier than Plinko. The gimmicks also aren't any offense to the game; it's a sign of a choice by a director. I still feel a bit uneasy that the show with the daytime show with the most money given out was because of a "double the prize" gimmick paired with Pay the Rent.

Quote
Pay The Rent has take away Plinko's long time saving grace of being the highest cash game. Moreover unlike Plinko, Pay The Rent has been won a few times

I'll give you that Plinko doesn't give away $50,000. However, tell me that Pay The Rent has been played for $1,000,000. If you cite gimmicks of other games as a reason why the current game isn't the best, I have to logically call you out on that.

Quote
pricing games not normally played for high cash amounts have given away more than Plinko has in one playing.
Quote
Furthermore its set is ugly, the gimmicks fall flat over and over. It's an old hat but it somehow mesmerizes people like car keys in front of a baby.

Frankly, that line of arguing seems to contradict itself. Although the gimmicks of Plinko have failed, gimmicks of easier games have given away more than Plinko is all I get from that. I get this is to further drive that Plinko isn't the "Big Money" game that the show wants to display, but isn't that the point of the $1,000,000 events?

Quote
The only positive is the SP portion being unique even if it's a 50/50 set up.

...as opposed to being a 33/33/33 set up? I understand wanting to judge it based on pure pricing ability, but personally, its a pricing game, meaning that a game doesn't need to be 100% on pricing.

Again, I'm more indifferent to Plinko, but I'm willing to have fun discussing other points of views on pricing games.
"If any show, forget sports, Price is Right, [the audience is] the star of the show. Somebody... coming on down and losing their minds, and ... crying, that's the show. The show isn't me, the show isn't necessarily [a] can of soup, how much that is, it's watching people go bananas, and there's going to be some of that missing."

-Drew Carey, interview with The Athletic, September 16, 2020

"I honestly thought the doubler was gone, but 9821 going $0 makes sense"

-thatvhstapeguy, Discord message, April 5, 2023

Episodes attended: 4/25/19 (8674K), 4/23/20 (9124K), 9/27/23 (303L), 2/5/24 (481L), 2/15/24 (494L), 3/14/24 (544L), 3/18/24 (531L), 10/11-16/24 (725-733L), 2/26/25 (913L), 3/7/25 (925L), 4/7-8/26 (1372-3L), 10/27/26 (1552L)

Offline WOF85

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 55
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #51 on: July 14, 2019, 02:06:59 AM »
I base it off the definition of the show. 50k is required for Plinko to be considered a win.

As for Rat Race if all 3 chosen rats did not finish, I feel like there's some hidden rule that they would still get the 3rd prize by default.

True about Secret X and Pass the Buck. However unlike Plinko as long as the contestant does not wipe out they still have a chance to fully win the game. As for a 3rd pick Lose Everything in PTB that's more on the contestant being greedy than the fault of the game itself, but yes you are correct. Also since Pass The Buck is a car game it does get the free pass of still being able to lose at the end despite excellent playing up to that point. (Like how Gas Money can have 9k on the line only to be lost.)

3 Strikes these days is sort of in it's own league (No pun intended). As it's become one of the oppulente car games. So it's car game pricing game challenge, but to a much higher degree.

As for Joker well it was basically a medium prize 5 Price Tags, and it sucked as a result. The fact 5PT is a car game is why it can get away with the still a chance to lose aspect despite a perfect 1st half, whereas Joker could not pull off that kind of leeway.

Normally gimmicks are no harm no foul, but Plinko has suffered an extensive number of gimmick ideas that yield underwhelming results. Like how much the Plinko special bombed. And even when the 1 Million is played for, the second a SP is missed you instantly know it's dead in the water. While other games may be easier they have the advantage of keeping the result a surprise until the end. 

I guess I should have elaborated on the highest cash prize. I meant on any normal day of the show. So not counting gimmicks. And even on normal days PTR has been won.

The 50/50 is just a moot point as it plagues many pricing games. It does not hurt Plinko but it doesn't really help it. It's just par for the course. 
« Last Edit: July 14, 2019, 02:17:17 AM by WOF85 »
Plinko is the worst game the show ever made.

Offline Trevor Tuominen

  • In Contestant's Row
  • ***
  • Posts: 180
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #52 on: July 14, 2019, 12:42:18 PM »
So this means you hope to see it retired? Find it grossly overrated?
"Take your job seriously, but don't take yourself too seriously." - Alex Trebek, 1940-2020

Icon by Siahri!

Offline WOF85

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 55
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #53 on: July 15, 2019, 01:02:00 AM »
So this means you hope to see it retired? Find it grossly overrated?

It's grossly overrated for sure, but I know it's a pipe dream to see it get the boot now. As it's weaseled its way to the most beloved pricing game and the show's poster child. If only it got booted early on where it was treated like any other pricing game.
Plinko is the worst game the show ever made.

Offline muteKi

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 66
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #54 on: May 01, 2021, 03:10:19 AM »
A lot of people really like fireworks. It's not hard to see why -- they might be pure spectacle, but the spectacle they provide is incredible. On an otherwise quiet, dark evening, they provide loud and incredibly bright and colorful displays. They're practically synonymous with some public holiday displays. And while they're extremely exciting, you really shouldn't get too close to them. One time when I was maybe 8 or 9 I attended a 4th of July baseball game that was supposed to end in fireworks. While the obligatory Neil Diamond played on the stadium sound system, the night sky was as black as any other, no delightful signs showering the sky. Turns out there had been an accident and one of the fireworks operators blew his hand clean off.

Sure, by the standards of potential injuries on this show, Plinko can't compare to the omnipresent Showcase Showdown where a great many contestants have lost their balance over the years. Heck, Dice Game probably has it beaten in terms of damage inflicted on contestants. But in a more figurative sense, as much as I've had a fondness for the excitement and intensity of a good game of Plinko, from its dramatic intro all the way to the last dramatic fall of the final chip, I never want to be the one standing at the board.

And I do think there's a lot to like about Plinko. I'm quite fond of the unique prize pricing that the game has -- having to choose either the first or last digit in the price of a 2-digit product. Since Plinko is focused primarily on the winning of cash (to the point that the goal of winning up to $25K initially and $50K more recently), the prices of the products can be kept low. Generally Plinko's prizes are given reasonable challenges to price, where prizes where the first digit is wrong have their true price far away enough from that first digit's value that even a passing familiarity with the prizes is all that's necessary to win. You don't expect to see a price where the real prize is 49 having 59 shown (i.e., making 50 a reasonable guess as a price estimate). The only other game that does this that comes to mind is Master Key -- which is a game that I'm reasonably fond of, and like Plinko is played for a relatively high-valued prize that also isn't a guaranteed win with perfect play.

And the spectacle, absolutely delightful. Almost from the start the show knew they had a winner on their hands. By a month after its debut at the start of 1983, they lead in with the hook from funky little jazz cue ("The Cats"), draw up some intense lighting contrast, and have the camera zoom in and out on the board showing the potential $25K available to win.

Ah, but there's the rub. Plinko has never been won. I won't say Plinko will never be won, but it's quite possible many people posting here will never live to see it. With ideal odds (dropping in the center of the board), the likelihood of reaching the center (top-valued slot) is about 22%. Doing this 5 times in a row is something that has an expected occurrence of once out of every 1,940 playings. I have no idea how many times Plinko has been played, but if we presumed once a week for the nearly 40 years since it debuted, we'd expect one win, but we've done 4 for the 5 available chips at the most once or twice I believe.

That's not to say I think Plinko's a scam. Actually, with 5 chips and a 22% likelihood, most players can expect getting the 10K space at least once, and that tends to happen with the regularly you'd expect. It may not be quite the excitement promised, but what of games like 1/2 Off or Punch-a-Bunch? Those have, in most occasions, 10K as their top winning prize, and neither come anywhere close to guaranteeing it either. As pure cash games go, Plinko, despite its randomness, comes across as genuinely generous. Heck, one of the chips is given to the player just for reaching the stage; sure, any punch in Punch-a-Bunch wins something, but so many of those spaces don't even compare favorably to the small prizes used to play for punches these days, encouraging players to stop before potentially revealing the big prize if they encounter a value that's merely pretty good.

Really if I had any complaint about Plinko it's that the probabilistic elements of it being the focus draw away from the greater concept of the show; while TPIR and Plinko may be synonymous in the public consciousness, they don't have much in common with their conceits at all, to the point where you can walk into Target and, like buying a box of sparklers from a street vendor, can get yourself your own very safe little replica Plinko board for like $40, and play to your heart's content, not even having to wait 10 years between sessions. I have heard rumors that the primary uses of these things is to facilitate drinking games for college kids; take a shot of whatever's under the slot the chip lands on.

That said, from a drama standpoint, even beyond the spectacle they use to launch the game, Plinko has it in spades. While the most likely space to land on from a chip dropped in the center is the 10K spot, the second most likely is either of the 0s. Taken together, they're the more likely space. Winning big comes at a big risk of winning nothing at all. While dropping the chip from the edges of the board tends to make it easier to win a safe few 100s or 1000s, people want the big money, and playing for it means that a chip looking like it could easily land in that 10K spot could just as easily, right at the end, wind up winning absolutely nothing. It's tense, and it takes long enough for that chip to get down that it becomes stressful in a way that most other games take some finesse to manage, like taking a minute to reveal that last car digit in Temptation, but effortlessly. Any jackass could host this show (ps if anyone from Fremantle is reading this, let me know where to direct my audition tapes), and people would still love Plinko, because it's all set up to create drama on its own.

If anything I'm maybe a little more fond of Plinko now that I've written out this review. As long as you can get around the fact that the lofty promises of FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS are little more than a pipe dream, it's a pretty dramatic little game that's easy to understand and always compelling to witness.

Offline pricefan18

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 1916
Re: New Pricing Game Review: PLINKO
« Reply #55 on: May 01, 2021, 12:54:14 PM »
Ah, but there's the rub. Plinko has never been won. I won't say Plinko will never be won, but it's quite possible many people posting here will never live to see it. With ideal odds (dropping in the center of the board), the likelihood of reaching the center (top-valued slot) is about 22%. Doing this 5 times in a row is something that has an expected occurrence of once out of every 1,940 playings. I have no idea how many times Plinko has been played, but if we presumed once a week for the nearly 40 years since it debuted, we'd expect one win, but we've done 4 for the 5 available chips at the most once or twice I believe.

Unless there is a confirmed second $20k win in the $25k era of the show (which as far as I know there is not), it's likely that there has been to date just one time that 4 of 5 chips hit the big slot (still hope to see that one day, as the episode it occurred in has not been in circulation since its' initial airing (or airings if reran in Summer). It's never happened in the $50k and above era, daytime or nighttime, so it'd have to have happened in the $25k one if it did. We may never know for sure I suppose, at least not until Pluto ran all the old Plinko episodes from that period, and even then some may be skipped over, but I'm gonna assume it's only happened once, seems a safe bet to me.