Well, since you asked so nicely...
I think PtR's point was simply that people should think about what they're posting. Seems like we've gotten a lot of content lately that had no thought put into it. I'm happy to put some thought into mine:
My listing:
1) Press Your Luck. I'm not sure how much of this is because of its own merits, and how much is because of what it isn't--namely Whammy!. This version is very faithful to the original, but with plenty of upgrades to bring it to 2019. The set is high-tech and flashy and makes extensive use of computer graphics, and they rely a lot on the "wow" factor (the first time the center part of the board flipped over my eyes tricked me into thinking it had physically flipped over before I realized the whole center part is an LED screen)--but it all fits together. Elizabeth was a little stiff and rehearsed on the preview episode, and they had terrible contestants, but on the first actual (?) episode both were better, and showed that this format can absolutely work in 2019. The bonus round...well we don't dwell on that since we know everyone's feelings about it, but if that's the price for getting a half-hour of classic gameplay at the top of the hour, I can live with it. (To put this in perspective--in a normal week I watch exactly one hour of broadcast television, and that's Supernatural when it's in-season; I tuned in for both episodes of PYL last week and I'll be tuning in this coming week too.) The use of the classic sound effects is great; I'm a bit disappointed that we don't have the classic "boingggg" of the Whammies popping up, and that the board sound is the GSM one, but again, small prices to pay for Whammy animations that are in the style of the classic show (and have I mentioned--YAY for including the classic ones) when it was probably very tempting to do them all in CGI like Whammy did. The theme music is my only genuine complaint--they took 14 seconds of the original theme and looped it. It was probably a cost-cutting measure, but it's a disappointment not to hear the entire thing re-orchestrated.
(Disclaimer: PYL is the only one I've seen a full episode of, the rest are being judged by clips I've seen.)
2) The $100,000 Pyramid. To look and listen to this one (set and theme music) they seem to be trying to be faithful to Pyramid's roots in the same way they are with PYL. From the clips I've seen, Michael seems a capable host (the first clip I saw had him on the floor after someone said the P-word), who wants to have fun with things...which immediately made me think "thank GOD he's not going for outrage like Steve Harvey does, what a welcome change." I was never really into Pyramid during the Dick Clark days (saw it during the USA rerun days), but it seemed a clever enough format; I saw the Donnymid years in first run broadcast, and it struck me as trying too hard to be modern with the high-tech set and that godawful theme music. From what I can gather, Strahan's version gets it right.
3) Match Game. Going by what little I've seen in clips, they seem to want to have as much fun on this show as they did in the Gene Rayburn days. I can't really offer substantive comments because I haven't seen a full show.
4) Celebrity Family Feud. This one gets points only because of familiarity with the name and with the format. I appreciate that there's a primetime version of Family Feud on the air for us to enjoy, but I'm overexposed to Steve Harvey's Feud as it is, and from what I can gather they do the exact same schtick on this one that they do in daytime. Other than its flashier set (make no mistake, I love gameshow sets that are homages to the classic versions, but are still high-tech), I'm not really sure what this one has to offer.
Honorable mentions: Card Sharks and To Tell the Truth. I never saw their original incarnations, and as much effort as they're obviously putting into the reboots to judge by their promos, I'm just not interested.