Author Topic: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK  (Read 2632 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Chelsea

  • Executive Producer
  • **********
  • Posts: 708
New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« on: October 03, 2012, 01:01:56 AM »
(Note: The last new pricing game review was Balance Game '06.  I'm coming in to pick up the games that've debuted since. Also, my reviews tend to be very concise and focus on a couple of key observations of the game.  Scored 1 to 10, 10 is best and 1 is worst)

Stack the Deck is a game whose outcome often seems to rely on the common sense of the contestant.  A contestant who wastes one of their digit reveals on the ten-thousands digit, for example, is almost sure to lose - while a contestant using their guesses on later digits is far more likely to be successful. 

It's a good game, but it's not my favorite game in the rotation - certainly not my least favorite  thought 7/10.

Offline goldroadfanatic

  • 2/22/2024
  • TPiR Alumnus
  • *
  • Posts: 8379
  • One Dollar!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #1 on: October 03, 2012, 01:28:04 AM »
Stack the Deck was a very creative idea-take the numbers in the price of a car and shuffle them in a deck of seven cards, which includes the price of the car and two fakes.  It's up to the contestant to take the correct numbers and place them in the right order.

The game uses 1 Right Price to allow a contestant to earn free numbers, which is unlike any other fee game in the rotation (Secret "X" and Pathfinder use Double Prices, Spelling Bee uses Range Game to an extent).  Also, this is the first grocery item game since Telephone Game where the car's price is relevant to gameplay.

The set itself is cool-looking with black and blue, offset with the playing cards with dollar signs and asterisks as the suits, and how the logo disappears to reveal the price is very neat.  The split screen used when a contestant decides on a product to associate the 1 Right Price with is a nice touch.

What's frustrating is that since Season 37, a challenging game has become ridiculously difficult thanks to hard grocery product setups, which prevents contestants from earning enough numbers to make the game easier to win.  Also, it doesn't help when contestants do earn free numbers, they choose to see the first or second digit (sometimes by mistake, and the contestant realizes this), rather than the fourth or the fifth.

Overall, it's still a challenging, in a good way, game, and despite the hard setups of late, I give it a 7/10.
"Cherish the past, accept the present, and anticipate the future.  They are listening to feedback wherever feasible, but they can't repeat the past."

Offline stardf29

  • Taking a Bonus Spin
  • *****
  • Posts: 626
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #2 on: October 20, 2012, 02:13:48 PM »
Here's another game where the concept is solid, but poor execution by the current regime makes it agonizing to watch.

I like these GP/SP games where knowledge of the GP/SP prices assists you with the pricing of the car, but you still have to price the car. Concept-wise, I guess my biggest problem with this game would be how, even with 3 GPs correct, it's still oftentimes a 1/3 shot at the final price (particularly if you go for the second digit, which isn't always a bad idea), and missing even one GP really kills your chances at winning the game. I'd probably make it so the contestant has to choose from 6 numbers instead of 7, just to make the odds better at the end game.

Still, the big problem remains that the current regime likes to make the GPs brutally hard, so contestants usually only get one free digit, which makes the game near-impossible (though there was that one girl that somehow still won). Add in deceptive cars and really odd combinations of the last three digits, and you have a game that I dread when it comes up.

Concept: 7/10
Execution: 1/10

Offline DJTorgo

  • TPiR Alumnus
  • *
  • Posts: 1935
  • Essential to the Experience
    • Torgo Entertainment
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #3 on: October 23, 2012, 10:21:59 AM »
On paper, this game is solid.  Granted, it can be tweaked to be nigh-impossible with hard GP setups, but the concept is fine as is.  The set is appropriate, the colors pop, and everything works mechanically.

7/10
Torgo has left the building. John and I never really cared for the way he presented himself.

Offline Jordanar18

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 4202
  • Currently, I live in the past.
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #4 on: May 26, 2013, 11:50:51 PM »
For a car game, this one's only okay.  Just pick out the right numbers in the car and you win the car.  Pretty simple.

On the other hand, it's got a lot going for it.  The GP portion is unique to it, set is decent and the price reveal -- fantastic!  One of the best on the show.

Frequency seems to have dropped off lately.  Should be played every other week or so.

Overall: 7/10
Episode 22 of Jordanar18's Price is Right starts Friday, March 8th.  Check out the Host Your Own section!

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #5 on: January 26, 2014, 01:11:50 AM »
Stack the Deck is a decent game. It's not 1 of my favorites but I do like it. The GP portion is my favorite part of the game. The concept of showing a price and having the concept which grocery item the price belongs to is unique to this game and a good pricing concept. Then there's an intelligence factor to this game. Cleary the smart thing to is to use your 1st earned pick on the tens digit as that's the most random digit in the price of a car. If you earn all 3 picks you should then take the hundreds and ones digit and leave yourself to pick the ten thousands digit and the thousands digit which are the true value of the car. I don't particular care for the car pricing portion. If o or 1 picks are earned then it's super hard. If all 3 picks are earned and the contestant is wise it often comes down to common sense 50/50 shot. Perfect pricing ensures a win so that's good. And even in longshot cases I always feel the reveal is suspenseful. Overall Stack the Deck is not a special or favorite game but it is a good 1. 7 out of 10.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #6 on: March 01, 2014, 03:18:50 PM »
Here's my more detailed review of Stack the Deck based on 6 categories. The 1st 3 of these categories,test of pricing skill,fun,and fairness will deal with gameplay aspects. The 2nd 3 of these categories,set,sound effects,and reveal will deal with intangibles. The other category will address anything miscellaneous.

Test of pricing skill: 10 out of 10: 1 Right Price for grocery items is a very good test of pricing skill as it requires contestants to evaluate 2 items and determine which 1 has the shown price so it has good value judgment. What makes this part of Stack the Deck a better test of pricing skill than the game 1 Right Price is that it has 3 parts instead of 1 so it's not just a 50-50 shot because it also tests consistency. A more consistent contestant in the GP part earns the right to Stack the Deck in the car part. The car part is a strong test of pricing skill in the 1st 3 numbers but pretty random in the last 2 numbers as the 1st 3 numbers are the true value of the car. And intelligence comes into play. Don't waste a free pick on the 10000's digit. Do use a free pick on the 10's digit. Great combined test of pricing skill with a side factor of intelligence mixed in.

Fun factor: 7 out of 10: The play along at home factor is strong. The gameplay is unique and enjoyable to watch. What keeps this score from going into the 9-10 range is the high loss rate.

Fairness: 10 out of 10: Perfect pricing stacks up a win every time. Stack the Deck is a fair game.

Set: 7 out of 10: Blue and black work fantastically well together and  the white and yellow parts of the set fit in nicely so the color scheme is good. And while there's nothing too special or exciting about this set it looks very nice and has a feeling of belonging to the 21st century.

Sound effects: N/A: Stack the Deck doesn't have sound effects.

Reveal: 8 of 10: The turnover reveal is somewhat unique compared to the more typical flip up/flip down reveals. Plus it is almost always suspenseful.

Other: Upon further review I'm changing my overall score to 8 out of 10. This is a very solid game
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #7 on: August 16, 2014, 08:09:33 PM »
My final word on Stack the Deck: While the current losing streak has soured me on this game somewhat I still really like the idea for the game. The key to Stack the Deck is setups. Ideally 2 out of the 3 sets of GPS should be easy and the 3rd set of GPs should have a medium level of difficulty. The game should be setup so that at least 2 free picks should be won most of the time. Then wins and losses come down to strategy and car pricing. If you setup the game for at least 2 free picks to be won an intelligent contestant will pick the 10s and 1s digits as their free digits and winning would come down to judging the true value of the car which is determined by the 1st 3 digits. I like the way this game incorporates the combination of GP pricing, car pricing and strategy but setups are crucial. I don't think slotting matters to Stack the Deck as it's really the same experience no matter where it appears in lineups. But the frequency discussion is interesting. As it is Stack the Deck is played about every 3rd week. In a thread about this game awhile back Adam suggested making this a weekly game so that with more exposure more contestants could pick up on and better understand Stack the Deck's gameplay design and strategy. The more I think about it the better idea this seems.  Stack the Deck is a game where contestants understanding of the proper strategy is critical so that might well help improve the win rate.  Stack the Deck has a strong premise and should be regarded as a quality pricing game.
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline pannoni1

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 1280
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #8 on: April 16, 2015, 10:12:47 AM »
Lately, I've been forking this game every time its shown up due to its current win rate of around 10%, or around twice a season. A big part of this is that you only get one chance to correctly price the car unlike One Away, Line 'Em Up, Cover Up, Ten Chances (most of the time), Any Number (often), Switcheroo, Pocket Change (most of the time), Pathfinder (most of the time), Lucky Seven (most of the time), Add 'em Up, Bullseye '72 (!), Five Price Tags (usually), 3 Strikes (most of the time), Money Game, and Split Decision (everytime it was played). In other words, almost every car game where pricing the exact prize is required, except for Temptation though at least that game is only 50-50 for each digit usually and offers a bailout. Even if you get all three GPs right, its no guarantee say if the price is $_ _ ,567 and the remaining digits are 1, 2, 3, and 4 esentially turning that final portion into Pick-a-Number for a car after you even earned the opportunity to have a 1-in-3 shot. This accounts for the game's low win rate, due to both poor contestant decisions on the free digits and often SNK Boss-syndrome setups. It's a shame since the Secret "X"-style reveal and the cool set give this game a good sense of presentation, and its frequency is fairly appropriate at around twice a month. Because of this, I'd like to see this game played more for cars in the $22000-$30000 range due to its degree of difficulty.

Grade: B-
« Last Edit: April 16, 2015, 10:15:29 AM by pannoni1 »
Now open for tape trading! Please PM me for an offer with a list included.

The list: https://yelimsexa.wixsite.com/pannoni1

Offline Declan127

  • In the Audience
  • **
  • Posts: 28
  • I like turtles
Re: New Pricing Game Review: STACK THE DECK
« Reply #9 on: October 27, 2020, 09:13:42 PM »
Honestly, it's a nice concept, but being one of the hardest games in the rotation hurts my rating for it. 6/10
Bring back Penny Ante, but have it with 3 prizes, one grocery item/prize, 5 pennies, and a $3-5K bonus for playing perfectly, and maybe, just maybe, I will enjoy the show more.

Edit: The showcases are better, so the show is being enjoyed.

ALSO WHO MISSPELLED PENNY "PENY" ON MY AVATAR?