On the rebooted Price is Right's debut episode, the original pricing games that were shown were ones that all became classics in their own right: Any Number, Bonus Game, and Double Prices. Well, maybe Bonus Game isn't quite as iconic as the other two, but it serves as the template for just about every small-prize game that's been on the show, from the very obvious successor Shell Game to less-obvious but intense games like Hot Seat. But Any Number and Double Prices may as well be the show's thesis statements, demonstrating what the show was about. In reviewing Double Prices, reasonably regarded as the lesser of the two, I wrote this:
There's a certain purity in the challenge in TPIR in general that surely accounts for its popularity, after all. You don't win on TPIR by memorizing the dictionary, no; when you're playing for a prize, you're playing for the prize.
Professor Price may not be about memorizing the dictionary per se, but its focus on general trivia is well at odds with the rest of the show and the simple accessibility of its challenge. Even more awkward is that its true and false questions are all necessarily about numbers, because the trivia questions are designed to relate to the price of the car being won. Heck, not even that -- the answers have to be one of the digits 0-9, because there's always a follow-up question about the digit as the first or second in the car.
Now, I'm not against trivia on principle. Back when restaurants could be open safely I'd regularly go to bar trivia at one of the nearby restaurants. The problem is that, maybe because of how restricted the answers had to be, a lot of the trivia questions aren't very interesting. "How many ounces in half a pint?" might be something that the average American ought to be expected to know, but it's a question that's entirely built around nomenclature or categorization rather than about some knowledge of the world, definitions of things that are, especially when it comes to the imperial measurement system, pretty arbitrary and not inherently meaningful. But we have to get that number 8 out somehow, because that car is $4857.
Even worse, the game required audience silence. I mean, yes, if we're talking relatively basic knowledge trivia questions then having the audience blurt out the answer breaks the game, but that also means it sucks all the energy out of the studio. If your game loses out in excitement to
watching a piece of plastic move up a board (I swear, Range Game tends to produce the most animated audience reactions of anything in the show), it probably doesn't deserve a place in the price pantheon.
Well, what if we did get rid of the general knowledge question of the game. Then we'd just be asking is __ in the price of the car, and so many games at this point do that that it makes Professor Price look silly. Temptation does this better. Heck,
Pocket Change does that better, and I'm not very fond of it. There are only so many numbers in a car price. And then there's the question about how picking numbers is even done. You'd need 3 distinct digits in the car price at minimum. Maybe the contestant would still pick a card with the question (well, a number) on it, then be asked if the number is in the price. While this works on a logistic level, it's awkward, and leads to an anticlimax (see: Add 'Em Up) because the contestant would win before the car price is even revealed, something that for all its flaws this game mostly prevents from happening. Now that car prices are 5 digits, trying to fix all but 2 digits like how the game was played means that we've just created a more drawn-out version of Stack the Deck.
And the setup that defines the game isn't much to write home about. Sure, as muppet-likes go the Professor is reasonably expressive, but the fingers used to keep track of the score just look terribly awkward, giving the whole game set a very uncanny feel. The moment the novelty wears off, it becomes yet another awkward element of the game. And that's the professor's only purpose, to stick fingers out to keep track of the contestant's progress. Well, that and help to reinforce the theme justifying the use of inane trivia questions, but clearly it didn't do a good job of that either.
As an attempt to complicate the show's formula, it's worse than Double Bullseye. As a trivia game, it's too restricted by its structure to be interesting. As a car pricing game, its basis in simple trivia means it's probably too easy for most contestants. As a prop, it's unsettling. It's almost a wonder the game made it to two shows, frankly.