Gridlock is a game. Hoo boy is it ever a game. They sure spent a lot of money on the set, for example, so it must be pretty good if they're that confident in it. At least, that was my reaction the first time I saw a picture of it. But then I saw them play it...
When explaining a game to somebody for the first time, most games are explained through a sort of duet between the host's words and the a visual of the set. While the verbal explanation is important, a set should give a good idea of how the game is going to play out. Yes, the host's explanation should be the foundation of the contestant's understanding, but the set should give an important clue. Cover Up and Line Em Up are hard concepts if you're only allowed to describe them verbally. Show someone the set and suddenly everything makes sense.
While a good set makes a game easy to understand, a bad set can kill it. Mystery Price, for example, had a kernel of a good idea, obfuscated by the set making things unintuitive and confusing, making it totally incompatible with Barker's explanation. Double Digits wouldn't have been too big a disaster, in theory. But the set, apart from being ugly, gave little indication what the contestant was supposed to do.
Anyways what was I talking about? Gridlock? Yeah, Gridlock's set. One day, somebody presented a great idea for a set with a highway mechanical cars, and the higher ups were so enamored with it that they had it drawn up immediately before they realized, "Wait a minute! We actually have to fit a game in there somewhere!" And then they drew up some quick rules, but gave little thought as to how how the two would mesh together.
That's a problem. Gridlock's set is pretty to look at, it's unique, it's cute, and it's imaginative. But it makes what should be a simple reveal waaaaaaay too overcomplicated. You know how they had to stop lighting up the contestant's guesses in Make Your Move cause the audience kept misinterpreting the numbers lighting up as confirming the correct answer? Well, this game takes that problem and makes it about ten times worse. The reveal is frigging weird.
"Look, the car's moving by itself! It's broken away from the traffic and now it's moving past all the other cars! Hey, if it's going forward that means it must be right! I'm getting closer to the end! The end must mean I win! Oh, wait, now it's stopped. Is that bad? Does that mean I didn't win? No, wait, now the numbers I said are moving. Hey, it's bumper to bumper with the right price! Hooray, that means I won, right? Should I cheer the car moving? No? Wait, Drew's asking if it was right. I have to wait for the sound effect? Oh, you do the magic car thingy even for wrong guesses? Huh. Oops. There's the buzzer. Guess I lost."
"Oh, I get another guess? Are we just making things up at this point, or..."
It's a simple concept, but Drew has to do too much of the heavy lifting to explain it, and the prop is at odds with the mental picture he's giving us. Which makes this should-be simple game a head-scratcher. It's unintuitive. And cause the game only lasts for 2-3 guesses, it's over before we can get used to it. In fact, I'm still not sure it exists and I haven't just dreamed the whole thing up.
Get the intangibles right and you can turn a quick, dull game into something memorable. Get them wrong and you just have a quick, dull game. Gridlock is an example of the latter.
★★☆☆☆