One argument no one has come up with: Five Price Tags uses the same principle of there being no guaranteed win for guessing all the small prize-related questions correctly.
However, in 5 Price Tags, you can still win if you know the price of the car regardless of how many small prizes you got right. In Joker, you win if you were lucky enough to discard the joker.
That being said, I've noticed many people (not just here but on other sites) say that they don't like Joker, because you can play your best and still lose. The same concept applies to Secret "X", Hole in 1 (or 2), Spelling Bee, Let 'Em Roll, Punch-a-bunch, Plinko, and a few other games. Also, in the case of the first two games I mentioned, if you lose, you win nothing. In Spelling Bee, it is possible to win money if you lose. In the last three games I mentioned, it is almost certain you'll win money. The point is that there are several games in which a person can play their best and still lose, yet most people single out Joker.
I've said it a few other times, but I believe that Joker is a misunderstood game and should not have been retired for a long time.