But if Joker were lost despite perfect pricing two or three times a season, wouldn't that be almost every time it was played

?
Really though, the whole "losing despite perfect pricing" doesn't bother me. Just one of many games like that. Even better odds than some other games. And quite honestly, it makes for a more exciting conclusion when played perfectly than in Bonus Game, which becomes sadly blah when played perfectly. And I may get smacked for it, but it's even better than when Shell Game is played perfectly. I think it was January 31 this season where Bob did a
great job of building up suspense with the reveal, with the contestant having won all four discards.
I don't mind all that, but I do mind that the game is an inferior Shell Game. Joker has an absolutely pitiful set on the turntable--I'm honestly not too big on the small prize stand either, but that's OK, anyway. Just getting rid of cards, hoping one is the joker, just isn't as cool as putting the chips by the shells, looking for the ball, with that whole thing based on that beloved classic con game. And Bob gets to interact with it! And whatever Bob does to build suspense, there's just something genuinely more interesting about Bob looking for the shell with the ball than watching Bob look for the card with the joker on it. Just is.
6 out of 10 on the old scale. Probably higher than you thought I'd give it.