Sure, it's overplayed. So was Plinko. But the reason I complained more about Plinko's old overplayedness was because it was replacing all the better games that could've been played instead. Double Prices doesn't really do that: instead, it allows other better games to be played! In other words, it's overplayed maybe, but I understand why it is, and it's a good enough reason, really.
As for the game... just pick one of the two prices. No bells or whistles or anything. Doesn't really pretend to be any more interesting than the gameplay actually is, which isn't much. Still, it does its job well of being an ultra-fast game. And it is an all-time classic. Even if not the very first game played, it just kinda' "feels" like the ultimate classic game, anyway. Just what it does.
And the set... it's current set is easily the best set the game's ever had. Not that it's much of a set, but then again, what's it really need, anyway?
6 out of 10 on the old scale. I have to give it fair recognition for the game's purpose and classic status, but in the end, it's still pretty boring.