Name any game who seems to have the most in common with another, and currently it is Shell Game with Bonus. However, it isn't quite the direct ripoff that the short-lived Finish Line with Give or Keep was, and for what Shell Game did made it more fun to watch. The biggest differences of course are the presentation and the possible bonus at the end. Of course the 4 SPs being Higher or Lower was the biggest difference, but if I created the game, I may have designed it a bit differently to give the pricing game portion variety: the first SP being Higher/Lower, the second SP True/False, the third SP being a multiple choice (one of two prices), and the fourth SP another Higher/Lower. Still, you can't deny the shuffling of the shells at the start of the game, the contestant having the opportunuity to control where s/he can place the chips, and the final reveal, often done to make it climatic. Since the bonus is not part of the requirement to win, I consider it extra credit and that's where I don't mind luck being a factor. My one jabber with this game would sometimes be if the prospect of a bonus is spoiled, though of course since any experienced viewer knows this rule, shouldn't be of much consequence.
Considering its similarity with Bonus Game, it isn't played too often and actually wouldn't mind it becoming a game played once every three weeks. It makes a great game at any point in the lineup, and occassionally is played for a car. Overall, a game that built upon a very good one and turned it into an excellent one.
Grade: A-