Author Topic: New Pricing Game Review: SHELL GAME  (Read 14380 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: SHELL GAME
« Reply #30 on: February 12, 2014, 01:38:32 AM »
Here's my more detailed review of Shell Game based on 6 categories. The 1st 3 of these categories,test of pricing skill,fun,and fairness will deal with the gameplay aspects. The 2nd 3 of these categories,set,sound effects,and reveal will deal with intangibles. The other category will address anything miscellaneous.

Test of pricing skill: 9 out of 10: The higher/lower is a good concept. Having to judge whether an item has a higher or lower ARP than the shown price is a good test of pricing skill. And Shell Game tends to feature harder setups than most SP games.

Fun factor: 10 out of 10: The higher/lower concept provides a strong play along at home factor. Shell Game is obviously more interactive than Bonus Game with the contestant placing the chips by the shells. In Shell Game the gameplay and the awesome reveal go hand in hand to make the game fun unique and interactive.

Fairness: 10 out of 10: Perfect pricing ensures a win like it should. Shell Game is a fair game.

Set: 9 out of 10: Red,yellow,and black are colors that go very well together so the color scheme is great. The shape and design are good looking and fit shell game well. And the shells themselves are so neat!

Sound effects: N/A: Shell Game doesn't have sound effects.

Reveal: 10 out of 10: Absolutely 1 of the most fun and unique reveals on the show and that's inherit to the game itself. The lifting of the shells to see where the ball is to determine a win or loss is just a flat out awesome style of reveal. It's fun it's unique and it's awesome!

Other: I stand by what I said in my general review about Shell Game's rareness being a good thing. Since the higher/lower concept is hardly unique so what makes Shell Game so fun is the shell/chip/ball portion and I think the law of diminishing returns would definitely start applying to Shell Game if played weekly or even bi weekly. Being played about once every 2 months is just about perfect for Shell Game. And in spite of not giving it 10s across the board I stand by my 10 out of 10 overall score for Shell Game especially considering that of all the factors scored here I give set the least amount of weight in an overall score.
« Last Edit: February 12, 2014, 01:46:41 AM by moneygamelover »
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline moneygamelover

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 2723
  • Expecto Patronum!
Re: New Pricing Game Review: SHELL GAME
« Reply #31 on: August 11, 2014, 06:34:17 PM »
My final word on Shell Game: Shell Game is a treat every time it turns up. And while I still feel the game should be kept infrequent I now feel that a frequency increase to once a month would be okay. I don't want to see it weekly or biweekly because I do feel Shell Game is a special game because it isn't played all the time. But going to having it be a monthly game would allow a few more playings a year without overdoing it. Shell Game is a perfect example of how to introduce a luck factor while still keeping the game fair. The beauty of Shell Game is that it has enough of a brain to use enough SPs to allow enough chips to be won to cover all shells if it is played perfectly. Perfect pricing ensures a win like it should while you get suspense in all other playings. As for the bonus for finding the shell, I've come to like it in spite of some initial reservations. It helps add some suspense to those perfect pricing playings while allowing perfect pricing to guarantee the main prize like it should.  That 1-10-2014 playing was 1 of my favorite segments of season 42. Perfect pricing and the bonus cash won! That was totally awesome baby! Slotting is totally irrelevant here. Shell Game makes a great lead off hitter, a great closer, and a great game anywhere in between. Put it anywhere in the lineup and you've got something special that day. 1 final note is that I think the similarity to Bonus Game is overrated. With Bonus Game it's really all about 1 SP and you just don't know which 1 until the end whereas with Shell Game blowing any particular SP doesn't kill your chances. With Shell Game each correct SP increases your chances to win in a purely odds based way with no SP carrying particular weight. I like having both concepts on the show. So while both games use the higher/lower concept it's the difference in the  " 1 important SP." concept of Bonus Game VS the truly odds based nature of Shell Game that creates the difference that makes both games worth having. I must also say that if I were a contestant I would love to play this game. It looks fun, it's interactive for contestants, and it's fair. Shell Game is 1 of the best games on the show and deserves all the praise it gets. Shell Game is totally awesome baby! :)
« Last Edit: August 11, 2014, 06:37:02 PM by moneygamelover »
Adjustments that should be made to pricing games to make them fairer: Secret X: Add a 3rd SP so that perfect pricing ensures a win. 1/2 Off: Add a 4th set of SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Master Key: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win. Rat Race: Add 2 more SPs so that perfect pricing ensures a win.

The following pricing games should be retired because there's no way or no easy way to make them fair: Spelling Bee, Plinko, Punch a Bunch, Pass the Buck, Let em Roll, 3 Strikes.

The following retired pricing games should be revived: $uper $aver, Give or Keep, Buy or Sell, Hurdles, Bump, Penny Ante, Credit Card, On the Spot, Split Decision, Add em Up, Walk of Fame, Barker's Markers, Magic Number.

Offline pannoni1

  • Double Showcase Winner
  • ******
  • Posts: 1280
Re: New Pricing Game Review: SHELL GAME
« Reply #32 on: August 21, 2015, 11:59:31 AM »
Name any game who seems to have the most in common with another, and currently it is Shell Game with Bonus. However, it isn't quite the direct ripoff that the short-lived Finish Line with Give or Keep was, and for what Shell Game did made it more fun to watch. The biggest differences of course are the presentation and the possible bonus at the end. Of course the 4 SPs being Higher or Lower was the biggest difference, but if I created the game, I may have designed it a bit differently to give the pricing game portion variety: the first SP being Higher/Lower, the second SP True/False, the third SP being a multiple choice (one of two prices), and the fourth SP another Higher/Lower. Still, you can't deny the shuffling of the shells at the start of the game, the contestant having the opportunuity to control where s/he can place the chips, and the final reveal, often done to make it climatic. Since the bonus is not part of the requirement to win, I consider it extra credit and that's where I don't mind luck being a factor. My one jabber with this game would sometimes be if the prospect of a bonus is spoiled, though of course since any experienced viewer knows this rule, shouldn't be of much consequence.

Considering its similarity with Bonus Game, it isn't played too often and actually wouldn't mind it becoming a game played once every three weeks. It makes a great game at any point in the lineup, and occassionally is played for a car. Overall, a game that built upon a very good one and turned it into an excellent one.

Grade: A-
Now open for tape trading! Please PM me for an offer with a list included.

The list: https://yelimsexa.wixsite.com/pannoni1

Offline tpir04

  • Taking a Bonus Spin
  • *****
  • Posts: 998
  • Why, oh why?
Re: New Pricing Game Review: SHELL GAME
« Reply #33 on: June 08, 2019, 12:02:37 PM »
This one reminds me of that Abbott & Costello bit...

Set: The original set was great, but the newer one does just as well. The old design had the pattern on the front, and the sign in the back, hanging from the turntable, giving it a nice old-style look, but the lowercase letters and the design of the ball going from shell to shell is pleasing as well. The textured shells are a very nice touch, and it's clever how they're padded on the inside so you can't hear the ball bouncing back and forth.

Gameplay: Very simple. Guess whether the displayed price is higher or lower than each SP. For every correct answer, you earn a chip to place beside a shell. If you place a chip beside the correct shell, you win! But suppose you get all four SP's right. You've already won, but you get a 1 in 4 chance for some cash! The bonus is a very nice gimmick that is exciting when the contestant succeeds.

My take: Again, the bonus is something you don't see on very many pricing games. At that point, you can't lose what you already have, you can only get more! However, I think that's a problem. You've already won the game, but feel disappointed because you haven't won more. And don't forget the blooper where the contestant accidentally looked under one of the shells. Bob certainly had a heyday with that one! My guess is that she wanted to "atone" for her mistake by sacrificing one of her chips, but Bob wouldn't have it.

The game is fantastic, and it deserves the praise it gets. But because of the aforementioned flaw, it gets a 9, instead of a 10.
CSS: Exacta, 6/3/2019
Lifetime earnings: $1,896,732
Season 18 cash earnings: $629,243
Season 19 cash earnings: $490,110
FPG: 2019-2020 Finals Champion
...............................

Live for the present.  Embrace the future.  Our favorite game show is still producing excellent, high quality, exciting, hour-long* shows every weekday throughout its traditional season window.  It’s as good as it’s been in a long, long time.  If the 1980s were the ‘good ole days’ for the Barker era, so is RIGHT NOW for the Carey era.  Don’t worry about what the future holds.  It will play out in due time.  Enjoy what we have right in front of us in the meantime!