I would have to agree with the general concensus out there, as I too have the same feelings about the premise for this game: it is basically Safe Crackers w/o the safe. Win two prizes by giving the price of the smaller (3-digit) prize.
To me, this is one of the more obscure games in the rotation, perhaps because of the frequency w/ which it is played. I tend to forget that this game even exists until it pops up all of a sudden, and then I think, "Oh, yeah! 2 For The Price of 1. I almost forgot about that game!"
That fact is now ironic (and less likely to happen) because it is now one of 17 pricing games that I have seen played in person (I saw it at a taping back on Presidents' Day earlier this year); I doubt that I will forget about it any time soon. Like many things on TPIR, this game is much more colorful and vivid in person than you can appreciate on TV. The game's lighted logo is actually pink in color, not white like it seems to appear on TV.
As for actual game play, it is mediocre, IMHO. Adding the total price of the prize package is somewhat of a help, as is the freebie digit. Typically a 1 in 4 shot, though sometimes that total price narrows the odds just a bit...
This game also holds a distinction of being one of only a few games that was created, designed, postulated (or whatever!) by Bob himself.
Slightly more exciting when played for a car, but overall I can only give it a 5 out of 10.
JBK