It's not surprising that Plinko has some of the most wildly varying levels of opinion on how good of a game it is. First off, Plinko is by far the most luck-based game on the show, even more so than Punch-a-Bunch since that has some strategies with regards to going on or stopping. But ever heard of classic game shows such as Treasure Hunt, Diamond Head, Deal or No Deal, Press Your Luck, Card Sharks, or Wheel of Fortune? They're all predominantly luck-based yet they are still enjoyable to watch. You still get some nice small prices for properly pricing items, and Plinko's pricing concept is unique among guessing which of the digit is the right price in that I'm surprised that this concept hasn't been extended toward other games that could include choosing the right digit among three or four numbers. It can also award a LFaT (sometimes referred to as a Joe Plinko based off of this game) as almost always a 0 and usually a 5 as the last digit results in that choice being correct. The current reveal is better than it was during the later Barker era in which you didn't even see the Plinko board being revealed with just a tepid $50,000 graphic, but it can't beat the Plinko sign accompained by The Cats. But you can't deny the set; that's what makes Plinko fun to watch with its great tall board, steps, plexiglass, neon dollar slots, and the prize stands in which its neat to see the models turn to reveal the prizes.
The suspense factor is where Plinko shines the greatest; from finding out if you won a chip to of course seeing where the Plinko chip lands really has that "what did I win" factor that could mean big money, small money, or nothing.
Most of us fans are probably familiar with the odds of winning the top prizes which are miniscule. But more realistically, I've done a similar calculation: the average expected amount to be won per chip. Currently, that amounts to $1466.66. This is based on the calculation of (10000*1/9) +(1000*2/9) + (500*2/9) + (100*2/9). That means random guessing for three out of five chips should still get you around $4400 and good pricing skill for getting all five should net you around $7333.30. While not a great amount, it is still better than the $5500 average on 1/2 off for perfect pricing and even above Punch-a-Bunch's, and its comparable to a win on a rank-and-file game. That said, based on the odds of getting all of the chips and landing in the slots and with 30 playings a year, we would likely have to wait until around the year 18650 to reach the 50th percentile among when the game's first playing should be, and by then Price may be taped in a galaxy far away. That said, the message of this game is "enjoy to have fun, but don't expect to see the perfect win in your lifetime." Overall, its popularity and mystique triumphs for the most part over the flaws it has with regards to pricing and fairness being not that great, but having that "playing the lottery" feeling always can be mind inducing.
Grade: B+